introduction
Winemaking is about capturing the elements. The subtlety of the
fruit, the soul of the place, the passage of the seasons, the passion
of the maker.
Bottling is about preserving these elements. Maintaining them
throughout the life of the wine, and at the same time allowing them
to develop and mature appropriately. In this process, the seal of
the bottle is vital.
While the closure in itself may appear to be of little consequence,
its significance is profound, for in it lies the ability to preserve
— or to diminish — the very subtlety, soul and passion
of the wine. It is the closure’s responsibility to ensure
that the wine emerging from the bottle is every bit as good as that
which went into it. The pursuit of quality in this area has been
the motivating factor that has led many winemakers to choose the
screw cap.
This book is about quality. The quality of the wine in the bottle
is the underlying theme of every chapter. This is the defining principle
of closure choice, and the foundation on which every aspect of its
use is based. The pursuit of quality is a passion shared by the
three contributing editors of this book, and is clearly evidenced
throughout their own winemaking. Each produces wines of a premium
standard, and has selected the screw cap to ensure that this standard
is not compromised.
The subtlety, the soul and the passion of these three individuals
are woven throughout the pages of this manual. The focus lies not
on the minimum requirements for the acceptable use of screw caps,
but rather on achieving the very highest standards of winemaking
and bottling for premium wines.
A unique closure
Product improvement and development must be maintained as high
priorities in any industry. For the wine industry, this has never
been more pertinent than it is today. In the modern wine world,
every producer competes on a global stage against an ever-growing
number of players. The market is more competitive than in any other
era. In response, winemakers and wine marketers find themselves
in constant pursuit of higher standards. More appealing packaging,
more deliberate marketing, more intricate vineyard management, more
advanced winemaking techniques – every avenue for product
improvement is employed in an attempt to create the highest quality
product in the most appealing package at the most affordable price.
Within this package, the closure is unique. It may be the last
important step in the winemaking process, but it is far from the
least. It stands out as the one component that forms an integral
part of both the appeal of the package and the quality of the wine.
In recognition of this, winemakers have spent centuries experimenting
with closures that endeavour to maintain both wine quality and aesthetic
appeal. In recent years, we have seen all variations of chemical,
enzymatic, radiation, steam and even genetic treatments for natural
corks, as well as membranes around corks, composite corks, two-plus-two
corks, synthetic closures, glass stoppers (such as Vintegra),
plastic twist-off closures (like Zork) and numerous variations.
It is apparent that there is no such thing as a perfect universal
closure, but after some thirty-five years of rigorous testing it
is now acknowledged that the screw cap comes closer than any other
to this ideal. Screw caps have been used commercially as wine seals
since the early 1970s, and are now recognised as a reliable seal
for all wine types. Many companies have accepted them as a closure
for their wine products in recent years, in response to continuing
problems with traditional closures. These problems relate primarily
to cork taint, sporadic (random) oxidation, flavour scalping (stripping)
and “corky” flavours. When used in conjunction with
the right bottles and applied in the correct manner with the appropriate
equipment, the screw cap provides a sound seal, offering the winemaker
and the consumer a high degree of confidence in package integrity.
However, discrepancies in the bottle, the cap, the application
procedure, the handling of the sealed bottle and even the chemistry
of the wine itself can produce discrepancies in the quality of the
seal and of the wine. Screw caps are an entirely different closure
technology to corks, and as such, bring with them their own set
of requirements and pitfalls for wine preparation, bottling and
storage.
Screw caps are inherently different to corks in a number of ways.
Screw caps form a seal with the outside of the bottle, while corks
form a seal with the inside of the bottle. Screw caps are manufactured
products which perform consistently. Corks are natural products,
with all of the inherent variability which this entails. Screw caps
provide a near-impermeable barrier. Corks facilitate, to varying
degrees, the passage of gases. Screw caps require strict tolerances
in capping procedures in order to produce a good seal. Corks are
forgiving and will adapt to overcome some imperfections in the bottle
surface. As a consequence of these differences, tolerances for screw
caps are less flexible and less forgiving than those of corks. All
parameters must be controlled to meet strict requirements.
These findings have come to light in recent years, as a result
of the increasing use of screw caps across the wine industry. It
has become apparent at the same time that a specific knowledge base
is required for winemaking and bottling with screw caps, and that
this knowledge is intrinsically different in many ways to that traditionally
associated with bottling under cork. It is the purpose of this manual
to bridge this gap.
Critical timing
The rate of uptake of screw caps in recent years has greatly exceeded
that of any other development in wine closure technology in any
period of wine history. Just five years ago, outside of Switzerland,
there were barely a handful of screw-capped wines on the market.
Today, literally hundreds of millions of bottles are sealed with
the closure every year.
This growth has exceeded even the most ambitious predictions.
Originating in Switzerland, Australia and New Zealand, the use of
screw caps has quickly spread to France, Germany, the United States,
Canada, South Africa, South America and elsewhere.
During the uptake phase for any new product, the demand for information
and experience regarding best practice is at a premium. The rapid
growth in the use of screw caps internationally has not allowed
time for adequate dissemination of this information worldwide. In
Australia and New Zealand, winemakers with experience have found
themselves in demand as consultants for their peers, in some cases
receiving more enquiries than they are capable of handling. But
outside of these countries, the expertise of such individuals is
less accessible. Winemakers have had little choice but to learn
“on the job,” and patch up any problems that are an
inevitable consequence of this approach.
The dissemination of information relating to winemaking and bottling
with screw caps has never been more crucial than during this current
period of rapid escalation in their use worldwide.
The international debate has quickly evolved from the question
of “Should we use screw caps?” through “Why should
we use screw caps?” to now “How can we best use screw
caps?” In the minds of many consumers, the first two questions
remain, and as such the industry should uphold them as priorities
as it seeks to promote the closure. But the key question that remains
prominent is that of providing the expertise that enables every
producer in every country to maintain best practice in the use of
screw caps. It is to this question that this book is addressed.
In recent years, the media has been quick to highlight problems
associated with screw-capped wines. Leaking closures, bottle imperfections,
reductive sulphide characters, oxidation, bacteriological contamination
and volatile acidity faults have all featured in the wine news.
It seems that almost every winery venturing into screw caps has
developed its own set of procedures and guidelines. In doing so,
mistakes have inevitably been made and lessons have been learnt.
More recently, however, winemakers have developed strategies for
largely avoiding these problems. While this pioneering process will
necessarily continue, a large body of information has already been
amassed from the many wineries currently bottling premium wines
with screw cap seals. This manual pulls together the expertise and
lessons learned from scores of the most successful wineries in Australia,
New Zealand and elsewhere.
Key expertise
In late 2003, I was approached by the contributing editors of
this book with an invitation to author this project. I was already
well familiar with the substantial contributions that these three
individuals had made to the use of screw caps as wine closures.
In 2000, Australian Winemaker of the Year and International
Riesling Winemaker of the Year, Jeffrey Grosset, led a team
of Clare Valley winemakers in bottling their premium rieslings in
screw cap. It was a brave initiative, for what were predominantly
small, family wineries, to risk taking on a closure that had previously
been rejected by the market. All the more so given the substantial
cost of having a new bottle produced and shipped from France expressly
for the purpose. The initiative was a resounding success, and Jeffrey
Grosset quickly became one of Australia’s leading authorities
in the use of the closure. His attention to detail in his own winemaking
is second to none.
Such was Grosset’s enthusiasm for the closure that following
a visit to New Zealand the very next year, a group of New Zealand
winemakers immediately established the New Zealand Screw Cap Wine
Seal Initiative, under the leadership of Ross Lawson. Key figures
in this initiative were Michael Brajkovich MW of Kumeu River Wines,
renowned for one of the New World’s most highly regarded chardonnays,
and Dr John Forrest of Forrest Estate, with wide experience in all
wine styles. Brajkovich served as inaugural chair of the initiative,
while Forrest’s expertise in chemistry proved to be invaluable
in refining winemaking practices for screw-capped wines. Both have
been strong advocates for the closure, and deserve credit for the
success that it has experienced in local and export markets. In
just four years, the initiative has seen screw caps mushroom to
account for over eighty percent of all New Zealand wines.
Grosset, Brajkovich and Forrest represent leading authorities
in the field of screw caps. They were conscious that their experience,
and that of their peers, should be documented in a manner that makes
it accessible to winemakers across the globe. The demand for such
information was further reinforced by the response to the First
International Screw Cap Symposium in Blenheim, New Zealand, in November
2004. The attendance of some 250 delegates from twelve countries
reiterated the need for the ongoing sharing of information and expertise.
To facilitate this, the International Screw Cap Wine Seal Initiative
was established. This initiative is responsible for funding the
printing costs of this manual.
Internationally, experience with screw caps as wine closures extends
over more than thirty-five years. We have come a long way since
the string of failed trials of the early 1960s. Equipped with the
proper knowledge, there is no reason why any of the mistakes of
the past need be repeated again. This manual taps into the collective
knowledge and skills of the most experienced winemakers, bottle
manufacturers, cap suppliers, bottling companies and consultants
in Australia, New Zealand and elsewhere. It presents a comprehensive
overview of all of the issues related to the use of screw caps as
wine closures.
Overview of contents
This book is divided into five sections, which detail all of the
subjects relevant to screw caps as the wine progresses from the
vine to the consumer. Each of these areas must work in synergy if
a successful seal and a stable wine are to be achieved.
Section one provides an introduction to screw caps, the history
of screw caps and twenty reasons for using screw caps. Wineries
must consider the unique marketing opportunities that the screw
cap affords, and a successful marketing campaign depends upon a
sound understanding of the reasons for choosing screw caps.
Section two introduces the cap and the bottle, emphasising the
crucial role that each plays in creating a good seal. The intricacies
of such details as liners, thread, tolerances, redraw, quality assurance
procedures and potential faults are explained in detail. Diagrams,
illustrations and tables are utilised extensively. Where possible,
specific manufacturer’s specifications and set-ups are outlined,
and common pit-falls are detailed.
Wine preparation requirements for screw-capped wines differ slightly
from those of their cork counterparts, and this is the focus of
section three. All aspects of winemaking and chemistry as they relate
to screw caps are discussed, with a particular emphasis on preparation
of the wine for bottling, dissolved carbon dioxide and oxygen, sulphur
dioxide levels and sulphide chemistry. This manual does not purport
to be a comprehensive winemaking textbook, but rather sets out to
supplement the general information already widely available, making
it specifically relevant for use in the context of screw caps.
The bottling process itself forms a major emphasis of this book,
and this is detailed in section four. Subtopics include filling,
capping, bottling line checks, capping equipment and torques. There
is a particular focus on sealing faults as well as specific technical
information and specifications provided by the companies responsible
for designing and manufacturing screw caps, bottles, capping heads
and other equipment. It is important that wineries are familiar
with the tolerances for these products in order to check and approve
the materials both entering and leaving the bottling line.
The specific requirements for screw-capped bottles do not cease
as soon as the bottle has been capped. Proper procedures for storage,
handling and transportation are detailed in section five. The final
chapter provides anecdotal evidence for the ability of screw caps
to sustain wines in excellent condition throughout long periods
of cellaring.
Finally, the appendices provide further, specific details backing
up many of the areas discussed in the text. Appendix 1 outlines
a sampling plan for quality assurance of incoming and outgoing products.
Appendix 2 is a copy of a report into the role of oxygen in the
ageing of bottled wine. Appendix 3 provides detail, diagrams and
specifications relating to brand-specific caps, bottles and application
equipment. Since bottle and cap designs are constantly evolving,
the diagrams and data provided should be cross-checked with current
manufacturers’ data sheets to ensure that specifications are
current. The industry is progressing rapidly in this field, so much
so that many of the finer details of the specifications quoted in
this book were changed between first and second drafts. A list of
recommended further reading and a comprehensive index complete the
manual.